HomeHardware › Netbook vs Laptop

Netbook vs Laptop

Reply to Thread
Rubin Goldberg
Hello all forum members I am located in Orlando Fl, and love the valuable information that everyone is contributing it really helps. Here this is my first question and would really appreciate any feed back.

I have been using Microsoft Streets and Trips for three years and have really had no problems with it. But have had some challenges with my laptop a 15.4' laptop set up in the car with MS S&T 2007 & a GPS receiver. I have been having problems with my laptop but not the software and would like to upgrade to a new laptop or Netbook.

Please note that I am in the car using the laptop from 8am to 8pm 6 days a week. And that we have 3 cars with similar setups.

What I am afraid off is buy a Netbook with a small screen and not being happy with MS Streets & Trips running on the Netbook.

Any suggestions would be help.
Ken in Regina
If you really use your laptop that much, you might find that the keyboard is an even bigger issue for you than the size of the display.

I've looked at a couple of the netbooks and I wouldn't buy either of them if my use of the keyboard was anything more than absolutely trivial. One has sculpted keys (eg. the edges are beveled and the tops are dished a little) so it's somewhat easy for your fingers to find individual keys, but the keys themselves were quite small and crowded together. The non-character keys, like arrows and page up/down/home/end/delete and the function keys were so tiny as to be nearly useless .. hard to find and hard to press without pressing at least one or two others.

And I don't have large hands. I'm 5'6" and have hands that are about average for my size.

The other has larger keys but the way they have managed to get larger keys into the same space is to make them completely flat. Each key has absolutely no tactile definition at all. It's impossible to position your finger on a key without looking directly at it and I mean taking a really good look as you place your finger, not just a glance. If you don't position your finger correctly and hit the key straight down, there's nothing to stop your finger from sliding a bit and catching an adjacent key.

I hated both keyboards, for very different reasons, and would buy neither. If I want small, I'll do it properly and get either a dedicated nav device with the features I want for navigation. Or if I want to manage contacts and have the contacts integrated with the nav software for routing, I'll get a PDA and run Garmin's Mobile XT on it. At least that way I won't be kidding myself that I've got a keyboard that's usable.

The issue with screen size has two components. One is for nav use and the other is for computer use. In both cases it's a matter of positioning and screen resolution. Can you get as much on the screen as you want, and, if you can, can you easily place it in a position that it's readable?

Nobody can answer that except you. We don't know how you use your laptop at present. If you use large spreadsheets, a screen with lower resolution will have you scrolling a lot more. But a smaller screen with the same resolution will require that you get the screen closer to your face (or your face closer to the screen, or better glasses).

Same thing applies if you prefer to have lots of map data and detail on the screen when navigating or planning a trip.

It's not rocket science. Check your current screen resolution on your laptop and compare it to the netbook(s) you are considering. If their max resolution is the same or less and you are very happy with your current situation, you'll probably be dissatisfied with the netbook. If the resolution is less, the problem is obvious. If the resolution is the same, the smaller screen size is almost certain to be an issue.

You will likely only be happy with a netbook if the need for smaller size and less weight, say, for vehicle mounting or for packing it around, is the most important issue for you. An issue so important that it outweighs the other ergonomic considerations.

The fact that you are asking the question indicates that you are on the right track.

In the interest of full disclosure, I do not have a netbook. I have not been able to bring myself to compromise. I have a full-size laptop which I use for trip planning but do not use for navigation because I can't find a convenient and safe way to mount it in my vehicle. And I have two (different) PDAs with integrated GPS that are excellent as vehicle nav devices and still have all my contact information in them and integrated with the GPS functions. I have not been able to find any middle ground, in terms of size and weight, that interests me enough to sacrifice on the keyboard issues. And if I can't get past the issues with the keyboard, the screen issues, for me, are irrelevant.

...ken...
Rubin Goldberg
Ken,

Thank you for the information.

I think I will stick to the laptop.

Have a great day.

Rubin
Marvin Hlavac
Hi Rubin,

:welcome: to Laptop GPS World.

Every time I find myself in a store that carries these marvels of technology, I just simply cannot resist, and I just have to go (again and again) to the section where they have netbooks on display . I'm still amazed how technology has progressed over the past few years. These mini-latops are just so powerful, so small, so light, and so inexpensive -- I'm not in the market for a new laptop right now, but I have been, on more than one occasion, tempted to buy one anyway!

A friend of mine, who runs a website/forum of his own, asked me recently whether one of these inexpensive netbooks would be sufficient for him to occasionally, during the day, while on the road, to check his site, etc. I told him basically what Ken mentioned above: potential dislikes may include the screen size and resolution. Each person may feel differently about this aspect of the laptop. If one is used to a 15" or 17" laptop, or a 19" or a larger desktop, it is difficult to say if a user will be happy suddenly downsizing to a 9" or 10" netbook.

My friend, after agonizing over it for a couple of weeks, phoned me on Friday to tell me he just bought his Acer Aspire One. He was happy with it at that time. He phoned me today (Monday) again, to tell me he (still) loves his new netbook. Screen size is a non-issue for him, keyboard is fine, and according to him the mini-laptop if very fast.

Each person's experience with a netbook may differ. One may love it, one may return it to the store the very next day.

I think netbooks are the best thing that has happen to the computer technology lately .

Setting up a laptop computer for GPS navigation is easy. Install software, plug in USB GPS receiver, and you are good to go. The difficult part has usually been a proper and safe mounting of the laptop in the car or truck. With smaller/lighter laptops, this will be increasingly easier. RAM Mounts, a company that manufactures mounting solutions for electronic equipment for vehicles, is going to start selling mounts for this class of small laptops (ETA end of this month, Feb 2009).
Rubin Goldberg
Marvin,

Thanks for the information. You site is really helpful. I will be going with a new laptop an emachine. They are running a sale for $399.00.

Thanks for all your help.

Rubin
pennyfarmer
Hello all,

I am new to this forum myself. I came here for some information on this very subject.

I plan to purchase a netbook this week for use as a navigational GPS in my jeep. I was thinking along the lines of and Aspire One with the Microsoft Streets & Trips 2009 along with the GPS receiver.

OK, I am going to say it. I am a geocacher that wants to have the optimize routing feature so I can hit my waypoints in the most efficient manner. Yes my wife gives me the evil eye everytime I want another GPS reciever. The geocaching aspect is also the reason I want a net book. I think being able to occasionaly access the internet while I am out is going to be a plus.

As for mounting it in my jeep, I plan to have my kids operate it in the passenger seat while I am driving. I may purchase a mounting bracket for it sometime in the future.

So I think I have my mind made up. I will post my experience here when I get my setup running.
Ken in Regina
Hi pennyfarmer,

If you haven't already, you might want to check out the forums over at geocaching.com. The section on GPS Technology would be a really good place to start with this issue.

A netbook would be really great for paperless geocaching. However, there is the issue of carrying it along. That's why most geocachers use handheld nav devices like the Garmin GPSMAP60CSx or Oregon or similar devices from other manufacturers.

If you are doing mainly urban caches where you are never too far from your parking spot, this might not be an issue. However, if you like to be a bit adventurous and get out for a hike as part of the fun, a netbook might be more annoying than fun after awhile.

I'm not sure how good S&T will be for geocaching. You should probably download the free trial version and try it out before you commit.

Another reason handheld devices like the 60CSx and Oregon, etc. are so popular among geocachers is that they have navigation features designed for hikers which translate into very useful features for geocaching. I don't know if you can get any laptop software that will give you a navigation compass that will point you to your destination when you are offroad and looking for the cache. This is a pretty standard feature on handheld devices designed for hikers and campers.

Have you decided what sort of GPS receiver you will use? And how you will manage to carry both the laptop and the GPS receiver with you as you hunt for the cache? (I probably have some thoughts on this if you haven't already got a good handle on it.)

Just some random thoughts...

...ken...
toyfountain
I sure like the Acer One for the size, but will not get one. Whether you choose a laptop or netbook, be sure their use is legal where you'll be travelling to. I'm seriously considering the common GPS just to be on the safer side of the law in case of accident outside of my province. Once I'm out, I don't really know anymore if I'm legal or not with my laptop.
Marvin Hlavac
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken in Regina
A netbook would be really great for paperless geocaching. However, there is the issue of carrying it along.
Just the fact that we are talking about it says something about how small and mobile these mini-laptops are.

Welcome to the forum, pennyfarmer. Do let us know about your experiences if/when you do give it a try.
pennyfarmer
Not to turn this into a geocaching thread, here is my experience.

I own a Garmin Map76csx that I use when I get out of the car. I also have a mio digiwalker that is my navigation unit for the car.

I think the netbook is my answer because of its size, ability to run mapping software, and access the internet at wifi hotspots. I want to have one of my daughters be the navigator and I think this will not be too cumbersome for any of them to use as the passenger. I would like to be able to optimize my route through the waypoints when I am doing urban caching. I can also load as many GPX files onto the netbook as I will ever need. I will be able to load my handheld gps on the fly and be able to load cache pages onto my palm pilot on the fly. Right now I find myself occasionaly unprepared to cache in an area because I did not load the correct files into my gps or the gps got too full. With the setup I plan to get I will be prepared without being overburdend by a full size laptop.
Ken in Regina
Hi pennyfarmer,

Yes, that sounds like the perfect use for a netbook. You will not be disappointed because your expectations are in line with what the netbook can do for you.

Depending upon your daughter's interest and attention span, you probably better bring the Mio along, too. Once the novelty wears off you might be back to using it as your navigator rather than your daughter.

Or make sure you put lots of tunes and a really good set of headphones on it to keep her amused on those straight stretches where there's nothing for the navigator to do.

...ken...
Marvin Hlavac
... or don't use your daughter as a laptop vehicle mount at all, and instead search for a more suitable solution (click).

Ken in Regina
I thought you were going to suggest his wife. Or one of the Budwieser girls.

...ken...
canadali
Can someone tell me how you guys using MS S&T with the Netbook. Because there is no optical drive on Netbook????????
Marvin Hlavac
Hi canadali, and welcome to the forum. To install software from a DVD onto your netbook, which has no DVD, you have several options, such as conecting to another computer via network to use its DVD drive, or using an external DVD drive, or copying the content of the DVD into a memory stick, or memory card, etc. However, in the case of Microsoft Streets and Trips it is even easier, since all you need is an Internet connection, which you already have set up. You can download a 60-day trial version of S&T 2009. The program is the same as the retail version. Use the activation code found in the retail box to activate the downloaded version. It's that simple.
pennyfarmer
Quote:
Originally Posted by canadali
Can someone tell me how you guys using MS S&T with the Netbook. Because there is no optical drive on Netbook????????

Yes I just downloaded the ms s&t from the internet with my desktop. I put it on a SD card and used that to install it. It worked perfectly. I am just trying to learn how to get s&t to do what I want.

I have to say that I am relatively pleased with my netbook.
Marvin Hlavac
Cool. Head over to our Microsoft Streets and Trips forum. There you will see a sticky thread titled "Tips & Tricks...". Some of the topics there may help in the learning process. Enjoy!
Thomas Birchmire
Hi:
I'm a geocacher and have been working on a laptop gps project for a while. In general the project puts the functions of a gps in a laptop/netbook so things can be portable. ( http://thomasofneedham.com ) My wife took pity on me after she saw me wondering in the Massachusetts woods with my Gateway and she bought me a Asus EEE 1000 for testing purposes. Eventually, the gps functions were coded into the netbook and I was able to go geocaching using my netbook. The next step has been to add a usb wireless modem from Verizon. This works as advertized and now I have intenet access in the woods around here. The most recent developemnt has been to put one of our(my wife and me) geocaches on the internet. This version allows an IPhone with internet access to get clues and directions in the field. Because I haven't written a location app for the IPhone, the player must use a GPS. There is also a laptop,netbook version that uses a usb GPS reciever to send location back to the server via usb modem. The player gets distance and direction to the cache from the server. When the player is within waypoint range, the server sends back directions, clues, messages that need and answer, etc. Geocaching brought into the internet age.
My wife uses her HP netbook with Streets and Trips for navigation.
Regards, Tom Birchmire
Marvin Hlavac
Hi Tom, and welcome to the forum. Thanks for letting us know about your wonderful project. Just this morning, while posting the following thead, I was thinking how excellent Trimble Yuma would be for geocachers.
Ken in Regina
Hi Tom,

That sounds like an interesting project. Great stuff for an urban geocacher.

I'm afraid it wouldn't work much for me. The bit of geocaching I do is mostly an excuse to go someplace interesting/different. In the end, as long is I end up someplace interesting I really don't care whether I find the cache or not.

Most of the places I prefer to tramp around in are outside cellphone range. And the ones with cellphone coverage aren't good enough for data connections. And in Canada the data plans are still outrageously expensive. If I can't get a free wifi hotspot I just stay disconnected. Which is not such a bad condition anyway.

...ken...
Thomas Birchmire
Hi:
Eventually, the internet will be universal and accessable from anywhere in the world. Right now the internet via 3g is useful around urban centers, but I'm programming for NNg service where we can geocache anywhere via the internet. I envision the possibility of multi-player GPS games as well.
Tom B
dtong22
Wow I was playing with a Sony netbook

http://tech.yahoo.com/blogs/patterson/32540

It is very very cool indeed. It is very powerful running Vista with 2G of ram - equivalent to a full blown computer. But its 1600x768 screen resolution needs some adjustment for users.

Running GPS program may have some issue with Vista

But meanwhile I am happy with Acer Aspire One


Daniel
Marvin Hlavac
Quote:
Wow I was playing with a Sony netbook

It is very very cool indeed. It is very powerful running Vista with 2G of ram - equivalent to a full blown computer. But its 1600x768 screen resolution needs some adjustment for users.
Lucky you, Daniel! I wish I could play with that Sony mini-laptop for a while. Here's more info: http://www.laptopgpsworld.com/1367-sony-enters-mini-laptop-market-gps-laptop-vaio-p

Quote:
Running GPS program may have some issue with Vista
I think by now all programs run just fine on Vista. I've been using my HP tx2000 (Vista) for a while, but haven't experienced any issues with any GPS programs.
frakdnet
I am planning to get a Asus Eee 1000HA netbook. I think it comes with 1 GB of memory.
I think I can up grade to a 2 GB module, but I was wondering if there is a 3 or 4GB upgrade?
remprimo
Just ordered a 1000HE. Hasn't arrived yet, but based upon my research, the 2 GB upper limit is hardware related and the system won't recognize any more than that.

If you find out anything different, though, I would be VERY interested in hearing.

Bob
DRIVINGGUY
Im a HazMat trucker around the southeast, Ive been using a HP1030nr as a Gps, using Co-Pilot 11, Xp/16gb ssd/, theres so much on the netbook I dont use, bluetooth/video camera/ I use it strickly for running the gps program, so far its been flawless no troubles. Kinda wish it has a low lit keyboard, My real gripe is the different Gps softwares, I wish somehow they could come up with a way a user could custom build there own, adding just features they need, where it could update maps weekly and automatically, they all have different features, some I need some I dont. And they dont list there features very well before you buy. I hope this will shake out in the future, but Im not holding my breath.
drivingguy
watchstone
I have a built in car pc. The screen is 7".
I have just purchased a Samsung NC10 netbook. By comparison the display, 10.5" is huge.
Keyboard is 85% full size, no problems so far. At just over 1.3 kg it is light enough to be held by a suction mount windscreen bracket.
Battery life is over 7 hours but I also have a car charging lead.
YES I am very pleased with the hardware

The navigation software is another matter
Ken in Regina
Quote:
Originally Posted by watchstone
The navigation software is another matter
Hi Watchstone,

What navigation software are you using?

...ken...
watchstone
Hi Ken,

I have just got PC Navigator 8. I had better post my problem in that forum.

Thanks for asking
jaman
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marvin Hlavac
Hi Rubin,

:welcome: to Laptop GPS World.

Every time I find myself in a store that carries these marvels of technology, I just simply cannot resist, and I just have to go (again and again) to the section where they have netbooks on display . I'm still amazed how technology has progressed over the past few years. These mini-latops are just so powerful, so small, so light, and so inexpensive -- I'm not in the market for a new laptop right now, but I have been, on more than one occasion, tempted to buy one anyway!

A friend of mine, who runs a website/forum of his own, asked me recently whether one of these inexpensive netbooks would be sufficient for him to occasionally, during the day, while on the road, to check his site, etc. I told him basically what Ken mentioned above: potential dislikes may include the screen size and resolution. Each person may feel differently about this aspect of the laptop. If one is used to a 15" or 17" laptop, or a 19" or a larger desktop, it is difficult to say if a user will be happy suddenly downsizing to a 9" or 10" netbook.

My friend, after agonizing over it for a couple of weeks, phoned me on Friday to tell me he just bought his Acer Aspire One. He was happy with it at that time. He phoned me today (Monday) again, to tell me he (still) loves his new netbook. Screen size is a non-issue for him, keyboard is fine, and according to him the mini-laptop if very fast.

Each person's experience with a netbook may differ. One may love it, one may return it to the store the very next day.

I think netbooks are the best thing that has happen to the computer technology lately .

Setting up a laptop computer for GPS navigation is easy. Install software, plug in USB GPS receiver, and you are good to go. The difficult part has usually been a proper and safe mounting of the laptop in the car or truck. With smaller/lighter laptops, this will be increasingly easier. RAM Mounts, a company that manufactures mounting solutions for electronic equipment for vehicles, is going to start selling mounts for this class of small laptops (ETA end of this month, Feb 2009).

How about connecting a second monitor to your laptop. You would keep your laptop in a padded case on the floor of your car, and see the navigation on your smaller, dash mounted LCD?
tcassidy
Keeping a laptop in a padded case while it is running is a bad idea. The heat it generates must be allowed to vent easily. Also dash mounted LCDs cost as much or more than netbooks.

Terry
jaman
I see your point. Than, even having a running laptop sitting on the seat of a car would me a bad idea. This is when a laptop mount becomes necessary.
Jerry.
Marvin Hlavac
...there are people who use dash-mounted LCD monitors. I have considered the idea, too. I haven't implemented it, but I may one day.
Thomas Birchmire
My wife and I do a lot of geocaching and our solution is a laptop desk for the passenger to use with her HP netbook. She runs Streets and Trips, GSAK (Geocaching Swiss Army Knife), wi-fi, and sometime the Verizon usb cell modem. We used to use one of our Gateway laptops, but the netbook works well. I first saw the laptop desk in one of our police crusiers.
Regards, Tom B
© Laptop GPS WorldContact